Law and disorder

France’s history of violence policing left a legacy of law and disorder, targeting dissidents, in its former colonies.

French regulars of the Colonial Infantry disembarking in Madagascar in 1895. Image credit the French Army Museum.

On June 2, 2020, tens of thousands gathered in front of the High Court of Paris to protest against police brutality and racism. Showing support to the family of Adama Traoré, a 24-year-old black man who died asphyxiated at the hands of the police in 2016, the crowd chanted, “Justice for Adama! No justice, no peace!” Reacting to the scope of mobilization, started in the United States and spread around the world following the murder of George Floyd, French pundits and politicians have tirelessly argued that “France is not the United States,” and that “comparing both situations is appalling.”

Yet, recent studies from Human Rights Watch and the national ombudsman respectively conclude that the French police’s checks on minors are “racist and abusive” and that “young men perceived as Black or Arab are twenty times more likely than others to be stopped by the police.” This is not a new phenomenon. In fact, as many researchers and activists insist, modern French policing draws its roots from centuries of institutionalized racism; today’s repressive techniques—harassment, manhunt, capture, strangulation—partake in a long obsessive history of seeking to subjugate racialized bodies.

In a June 2018 conversation with Assa Traoré, Adama Traoré’s sister and founder of the Justice and Truth for Adama committee, activist and scholar Angela Davis declared: “Police violence […] you are experiencing here in France as direct result of colonialism—the attacks on Black communities, Arab communities—is something that has continued unabated.”

Hence, President Emanuel Macron’s comments on the “noble struggle” against racism and discrimination being threatened by a “hateful, false rewriting of the past,” illustrate French authorities’ endorsement of inherently oppressive structures.

Indeed, France’s long history of violent, colonial policing toward Africans has structured the country’s police methods today. More than that, it is at the core of African states’ post-colonial relationship to dissent.

Further Reading

The Senghor myth

Once you’ve exhausted all the Negritude quotes, you have to confront the fact that Leopold Sedar Senghor ran Senegal as a repressive, one-party state.